‘Who Decides?’ is a feature documentary exploring the growing national conversation in Australia surrounding the participation of transgender women in female-only spaces, alongside broader questions relating to education, healthcare and public policy. As these issues increasingly move from sporting fields and schools into courtrooms, government inquiries and parliamentary debate, the film looks beyond the headlines to examine how competing rights, public policy and lived experience intersect.
Through interviews with people holding a range of perspectives, including those directly affected, experts, advocates, journalists, legal professionals and policymakers, ‘Who Decides?’ seeks to foster a thoughtful exploration of one of Australia’s most contested public conversations.
The film is introduced by Sall Grover, who is rapidly becoming Australia’s gender-critical superhero. Sall is as warm, compelling and articulate as always. A great start to the documentary. However, what follows is a horror show of how people, mostly women, have been monstered, vilified and threatened for holding views such as:
males shouldn’t compete in female sports;
men cannot be lesbians;
men cannot breastfeed;
effeminate boys and masculine girls do not need to be fixed;
freedom of speech is a good thing to have.
There are lots of people, right here amongst us in Australia, who believe that the above concepts are not only wrong but downright despicable, and that people who hold these views deserve punishment.
Australian courts have ruled that whether someone is a man or a woman depends on the clothes they wear and the length of their hair; that citing freedom of speech is unacceptable as a defence in law; that there are more than two sexes; and that calling a man in a dress a ‘bloke in a frock’ can get you into deep trouble! And all you have to do to earn special legal protections is to utter the magic words ‘I am trans’. Such views dominate in healthcare, education, arts and media, social work, therapeutic services and more. The list is frighteningly long.
‘Who Decides?’ explores these issues through a range of case studies which highlight some of the absurdities of gender ideology and the frightening consequences in store for those people brave enough to call out this nonsense. This film illustrates the harms of gender ideology by allowing people to tell their stories. All have paid a heavy price for speaking out, not least in their peace of mind.
Notable contributors include:
Courtney Colland, Deborah Acason and Kirralie Smith (Why are men in women’s sport?)
Dr Jillian Spencer, Professor Dianna Kenny and Jasmine Sussex (Why is healthcare subservient to trans ideology?)
Nicole Mowbray (Why are men allowed into lesbian spaces?)
Central to the documentary’s narrative are Tess and the truly dystopian ordeal that became her family’s life for several years. Every time Tess reached out for help, she was dragged further into the mire of gender ideology by so-called professionals who demanded unquestioning adherence to the most deranged aspects of trans ideology. Tess’s daughter gradually became convinced she was a boy, despite being a typical teenage girl. At every step, where Tess expected professional service providers to help, they did the opposite.
When a devastated Tess found out her daughter had been raped by a non-binary ‘friend’, the response of her daughter’s teacher was to advise the girl to put it down to experience and move on. This teacher was later found to have been encouraging his students to sexually experiment with each other.
Tess took her daughter to a medical appointment, expecting it to be an opportunity to explore and discuss options. Instead, the clinic nurse suggested puberty blockers for Tess’s 16-year-old daughter, who had obviously already gone through puberty. The nurse then offered cross-sex hormones. No-one offered counselling.
Social workers, psychiatrists and therapists all told Tess and her husband that they had to affirm their daughter’s new male identity. Challenging their daughter in any way was considered ‘transphobic’ and was met with rage by these ‘professionals’. They disdainfully told Tess and her husband that their daughter should be allowed to do exactly as she wished. Otherwise, there would be severe consequences for the parents, and their daughter was likely to kill herself if not given free rein.
When, in desperation, Tess phoned the police for help, they did not want to know and, following a familiar pattern, sided with the daughter and her supporters. Family and friends turned their backs on Tess. The process of scapegoating and ostracism was complete. Tess was trapped in a never-ending nightmare.
But here’s the thing: there are people like Tess (who continues to support parents caught up in this madness) and the other participants in this documentary who refuse to shut up – who, no matter the consequences, will not stop fighting for what they believe to be right. Every one of the people in this film could have kept quiet and had an easier life, but all of them stood up and used their voices to protest the insanity that is trans ideology. Would any of us be brave enough to do the same?