Last week, for the first time in the Victorian election campaign, the issue of women's sex-based rights was raised. We welcome the Liberal Party's announcement that it will not allow biological males to be housed in women's prisons.
One such case was Benjamin Charles Jones, who identified as Lisa Jones. Jones, a serial sex offender, was housed in a Victorian women's prison. A male serial sex offender in a women's prison.
Once you accept that women should be safe in prison, where next? Any custodial setting where the state provides care. Any institution the state funds. Then think about women's refuges and domestic violence shelters. Women in hospital wards, sharing with men. Changing rooms. Sporting fields.
Why does a lesbian, gay and bisexual organisation care about this?
Homosexuality is same-sex attraction. It relies on the biological reality of sex and on sex-based rights. We fought for same-sex equality, and Australians supported us. In 2017 we won marriage equality, an important civil rights victory.
Since then, gender ideology has spread across the Western world, and Victoria has adopted all of its key tenets. Women have lost the right to organise and socialise as women. Lesbians cannot hold women-only events. In Victoria, the definitions of woman, man and homosexuality have been changed to remove sex and insert gender. And the organisations that once represented LGB people now focus on TQ+ issues.
Children
Victoria is a gender-affirmation-only state. Our laws and health services support only one approach. Young people who show any gender non-conformity are assumed to be trans and put on medical pathways. Primary school children are taught that they can be born in the wrong body.
A child who is distressed about their sex needs care that explores the causes of that distress, not a single pathway decided in advance. Yet Victoria has never held an independent review of gender-affirming care for minors. Our laws have made it difficult for parents, clinicians and counsellors to take a cautious, wait-and-see approach without fear of breaching the law.
Funding and fairness
It does LGB Victorians no favours when funding for LGBTQIA+ organisations is politicised and handed out through secret grants. In Victoria, $6 million in secret grants went to bail out the Pride Centre. This isn't the first time public money has been used to rescue it. Last year, another $1 million went to a safety upgrade, with no public business case. At the federal level, the charities regulator, a tribunal and the Full Federal Court all refused a large LGBTQIA+ advocacy organisation the charity status it needed for tax deductibility. Parliament then passed a law giving it tax-deductible status anyway. Every other community organisation is expected to make its case, show need and account for public money. Exempting LGBTQIA+ organisations from that standard creates an exceptionalism around us that has no long-term value.
Why this matters now
Until last week, we thought this election would pass without these challenging public policy issues being properly debated. We understand why they are hard to discuss. They are detailed, they have a long backstory, it is easy to trip up on the detail, and they are easily misrepresented.
We say it is time to pay attention: to the safeguarding of women and children, to the rights of LGB people, and to the wellbeing of our whole community.
We welcome commitments from any political party to safeguard the wellbeing of gender-distressed children and young people, to keep young people free from a saturation of identity messaging and adult concepts, and to protect the freedom of women and lesbians to define who they are.
Our priorities for the Victorian election
We call on the next Victorian Government to:
Review gender-affirming care. Victoria has never held an independent review into gender-affirming care for minors. The next government must commission one, drawing on the growing and consistent evidence that the case for medicalising gender-distressed children is weak. The review must consider services for detransitioners and investigate the state's potential future legal liability for negligence.
Protect women-only services. Require all custodial settings, refuges and single-sex services to guarantee natal women safety, dignity and privacy, and to ensure natal men are not permitted entry to women-only services.
Review school programs. Review the Respectful Relationships program, and independently review all funded after-school programs, to ensure materials are age-appropriate and free of adult concepts.
Remove barriers to single-sex provision. Investigate and address the legal barriers to single-sex services, spaces and categories across sporting, social and cultural life.
Hold all funding to the same standard. Ensure all public funds, grants and programs, including those for LGBTQIA+ organisations, meet high standards of probity and transparency, and that the case for any funding or consultation is evidence-based and grounded in need.